Cost vs Benefit

From time to time I deal with cost benefit analysis at work and I’ve been reading recent discussions on the cost of veg growing with interest. It’s one fundamental question that all of us growing our own, or thinking of doing so, have to face up to: Is growing your own cheaper than buying your fruit and veg in the supermarket?

On the face of it, in pure financial terms, of course it isn’t. The statistician in me would like to work it all out (I wish I’d kept the receipts!). But when you start to think about allotment rents, or allocating a value to the part of your garden you’ve turned over to veg growing, costs of a greenhouse, or shed, tools, seeds, manure / compost etc it soon adds up. Of course in accountancy terms you’d capitalise a lot of this expenditure over future years as one off purchases will eventually pay for themselves but in the short to medium-term, say 5-10 years, there’s no way your veg costs can compete against the rock-bottom supermarket prices.

Fortunately we are not dealing with a black and white world. And when looking at grow your own versus the supermarket we’re comparing apples and pears, there are so many intangible benefits to growing your own which, if we could put a value on them, would far outweigh the supermarket.

So why do I do it?
1) It’s a genuine hobby and interest of mine. I love the satisfaction of sowing a seed and nurturing it to fruition. I suppose it’s a basic human instinct that many people have lost over generations. I also meet and speak to like-minded people, it’s a huge pastime in this country and as we are now in an age of austerity re-discovering a back to basics approach is seriously on-trend at the moment. It’s probably the one time that I can say I’m doing something fashionable in my life!
2) I firmly believe that it’s a hobby that reduces stress and blood pressure. In the summer after a hard day at work I can go out in the garden and all the concerns and worries of the day ebb away. Put a £ value on that!
3) I can involve my family in the process. My children will have that awareness of how things grow and where they come from. Vegetables aren’t meant to be uniform and wrapped in plastic. In time they can help out and this will be a lifeskill they can take with them into adulthood.
4) I can control what my family eats. I know exactly what has gone into producing this food and they eat it at its freshest. There’s no better feeling than watching my children tucking into fresh veg that I picked minutes before. Those of us who choose this path try to be as organic as possible so we are benefitting wildlife at the same time.
5) I can grow different varieties that I can’t can’t get in the supermarket. Also I can concentrate on veg that is more expensive to buy, such as sprouting broccoli, but I may not grow many onions which are cheaper to buy in the supermarket.
6) Seasons and Air Miles – 3 years ago I didn’t have much of a clue about what grew when and where it came from. Country of origin was a part of the label I never checked. Now I know that a butternut squash in May is from Argentina, Green beans in February are probably Kenyan and raspberries in December will be from the land of the Pharoahs! I still want to eat exotic things that can’t be grown in this country from time to time. But what can be grown in this country I’ll eat in season as much as possible. It’s fresher, tastes better, and helps cut down air miles. There’s the argument in some cases we’re supporting families in developing countries but shouldn’t we be supporting them to grow food for their own, and neighbouring countries?

There are also ways you can reduce costs. Take membership of a local Horticultural Society, Gardening Club or Allotment Association as an example. I pay £5 a year to be a member of the Winterslow & District Horticultural Society. For that I get 50% off my annual seed order. Stop there, I’ve already saved way over my £5. But I also get free entry to shows, where I can partake in a bit of friendly competition with other local gardeners, and access to expert talks such as the ones given by Ray Broughton, from Sparsholt College, where I have learnt things that I have never seen in books or on-line. And I can tap in to the collective encyclopedic knowledge of the membership if I need to. So £5 a year is fantastic value!

You can also save and swap seeds, recycle materials, make your own compost and leaf mould. The list of money saving ideas is endless.

So if you’re only interested in the £ price of fruit and veg stick to the supermarket. However, as you can see, there’s so much more to it than that, take this photo for example:

How can you put a price on that?


14 responses to “Cost vs Benefit

  1. I started to waiver at ‘cost benefit analysis’, but by the time you got to ‘capitalising expenditure’ I’d gone… ;>)

    You are right of course, having an allotment I’d throw in the social element of things too.

    Oh and the statistician in you might like to know you’ve got two no 2s ;>)

    • That’s the sort of thing I have to put up with at work, I’m glad I’m not an accountant! Mortified my numbering was out of sync, thanks for spotting that, I’ve now corrected. I’ve not experienced the allotment side but that must be a big factor if you’re on a good site.

  2. Here Here !! I agree with every word said. I certainly feel that the effort and cost in GYO is nothing compared to the benefits, all of which you have said for us. I love that photo of your girls.

    Have a lovely week-end.

  3. What a wonderful photo. It won’t be long until they’re getting their hands dirty with you. If you take growing your own as just a hobby, it works out much less expensive than some other hobbies, and that’s without all the other benefits which you list.

  4. We wondered about this last year so just for fun we kept a record of what we grew and how much it would have cost at supermarket prices. The value of our harvests was over £2000. Fruit was the highest value (some of which we acquired with the plots). It hasn’t covered a full 12 months yet.

    We bought our greenhouses ages ago when we hadn’t even considered growing our own – we grew lots af annual bedding plants – so would have had them anyway as ‘hobby’ expenditure. Then I supposed you need to factor in the cost of a different hobby – what would we do if we didn’t garden!

    As you say though we don’t grow our own to make a profit or to save money – mainly we just enjoy it and fortunately it comes with all the benefits that you mentioned.

    I’m afraid when we started we were considered to be anything but fashionable – more of a Tom and Barbara joke! But in the end we have had the last laugh! I’m afraid allotments sites do suffer from tenants who want to be fashionable and then find out that gardening is hard work and you also end up with dirty hands (in my case dirty everything – well almost) and broken nailes.

    • Hi Sue, that’s a great harvest, over £2000. We do it because we enjoy it and the benefits of being able to eat what we grow are a nice bonus – I used to spend £100s on angling as a hobby and I put all the fish back! And now you are right in the moment as grow your own becomes more and more fashionable. Can’t be bad!

  5. I truely enjoyed reading this and could not have said it better in my own words! It rang so true to me!!!

  6. Well done on such a thoughtful post, which I agree with wholeheartedly!
    I never really try to work out the actual costs of my plotting, as I do it for the inestimable pleasure and satisfaction that it gives me.

    • I agree Flighty, it would be a waste of effort as it wouldn’t change anything. The main thing for me is a realisation of the seasons and hopefully being able to pass on some knowledge to my children.

  7. oh man you make so many great points but that photo, well they say a picture can speak a thousand words – never was it so true! love that your angels love their veggies; would they be half as interested if everything came pre chopped in a bag and all tasted the same?? would they be as happy and healthy girlies?? much love to you all xxxx

    • Thanks Carrie and you’re absolutely right, they do love their fresh veg although have gone off sprouts at the moment but who didn’t as a child! It’s good to know what they’re eating and I’m hoping to get them more involved in the next couple of years when they’re over the throwing gravel into the veg bed stage!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s